Anyway, my point is this, not every aspect of my job is
light hearted and sometimes it can be hard.
No one wants to hear about the hard times, so I am going to blog about
them so it does not bottle up. Hence you
are not getting a funny and light hearted post today.
One of the challenges that I face is that in every
prosecution is that while much of the community
church protested his arrest. They made appearances and wrote letters in his support because he was their friend and Ted just would not do such a thing. Even murders have friends who want to believe they are innocent.
To illustrate this, I share an experience I had when I was a
prosecutor at the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office in Mesa, Arizona. I was assigned a child abuse case where the
mother of the three year old victim filled a bathtub with scalding hot water
and then held her little boys feet where they cooked in the water. Once his feet were done, she did the same to
his penis. This was a punishment for wetting
his pants. The boy learned his lesson as
he had third degree burns covering his feet and up past the ankles as well as
second degree burns on his penis. The injuries
were so severe that doctors has to filet the feet open so the infection and
swelling would not tear his feet apart.
He will never recover from the disfigurement associated with the
injuries to the more sensitive part of his body. The level of depravity associated with this
crime goes beyond my comprehension.
While I was not the original prosecutor on the case, I was assigned the case a few years after the crime to defend a request by the defendant to be excused from probation.
While I was not the original prosecutor on the case, I was assigned the case a few years after the crime to defend a request by the defendant to be excused from probation.
Now the reason that I am sharing this is because of a conversation
I had with my sister regarding that case.
Shortly before Christmas my sister and I went to go do a little
Christmas shopping. While in the car,
and making casual conversation my sister brought up this case, well at least the
version of the case that she heard. Purely
by chance, the monster that inflicted this abuse upon her son attended the same
church as my sister.
Not knowing that I was involved with the case, my sister
started telling me of the atrocity’s being perpetrated by the County Attorney’s
Office on this lady that she knew and asking if there was anything I could do
to stop it. As she explained to me “There
is a lady in my ward that is being prosecuted by your office and they won’t let
her see her kids or be with her family just because her little boy turned on
the hot water in the bathtub when she was not looking and got a little burned. What are you guys doing over there?”
I explained that her story did not sound right and that we
would not be prosecuting a case with those facts. I did not even recognize the case that she
was describing was my case until she told me the defendant’s name. Once
she mentioned the name and I made the connection I about flipped my lid, I was
so angry. That this woman would have the
audacity to do what she did and then attempt to paint a picture for her friends
as if she were the victim was beyond my comprehension at that time.
I quickly explained the real facts of the case and offered
to show my sister the pictures of the little boys feet, which she declined. She, of course agreed with me that prosecution
was not only appropriate but that this woman should not see the light of
day.
My take away from this experience is that almost everyone
charged with a crime claims to be innocent and tells people that they are being
railroaded and that the system is rigged.
Their friends then believe them… regardless of the facts. Again, look at Ted Bundy, he convinced
hundreds.
There have been innocent people accused of crimes, and my
worst nightmare is that I would somehow ever convict one, but those are very
few and far in between. Just keep in
mind that before you jump on the police and prosecutors are corrupt bandwagon
when you see a Facebook story that the writer has an agenda.
I learned that I had to grow a thick skin, heck even my own
sister was ripping me and my office for prosecuting this case. It is just too bad she
did not have the real facts of the case initially.
So, what’s my point to this whole blog, you know besides the school credit? The simple answer is that there are two
sides to every story, every author, including me in this post, has an
agenda. Just remember that when reading
posts on Facebook or in the news to be objective and notice the biases of the authors,
and before you repost that story on the corrupt cops, or the overzealous
prosecutors make sure that the atrocities that you are now sharing with your
family and friends are actually true.


I still have trauma from the first case you mention and I wasnt even in the scene. I just listened to the interviews and helped with discovery and motions. I still get upset thinking about it and it's probably been 5 years since I had anything to do with it and I did far less than the rest of our office or the PD did.
ReplyDeleteSo yes, it's a hard job. That others may be harder doesn't diminish that. And I think most people fail to understand just how horrific some of the things we deal with are. Either you harden yourself to it or you let it wreck you.
What I tell people is "You ever get depressed or angry at the local news for all the trageic stuff they report? Well 95% of even tragic cases never make the news. But we still have to deal with them."
Great post. I can completely relate. What is also frustrating is that when you do a good job and convict the guilty party, often, the victim or victim’s family are not happy with the amount of punishment meeted out. It often can feel like a lose/lose. Keep up the awesome work! I’ll keep reading
ReplyDeleteTruly a hard job and explained so well. I know I could not handle the jobs all people involved in these cases do. I can imagine the stress of your job.
ReplyDeleteAt probation, I always did it strange that when a person claims a drug test has a “false positive” result it is always for their historic drug of choice and never for a substance they have limited or no history with.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI remember a sex offense case, several years ago where a local man had molested several children. When he was caught, he mentally shut down and went into complete denial, so far, that he believed it himself and some of the community believed him as well. The rest of the community wanted to hang him.
ReplyDeleteAs part of his shut down, he went out and engaged in community service with those who believed him. Sadly, some of that gullible group included extended family. While his case worked its way through the courts, I was privvy to details, but couldn't say anything.
After sentencing, extended family was furious. "What if he was innocent"? "What if the kids lied"? they said, notwithstanding the absolute mountain of evidence against him. At that point, I did manage to state that if they could read the case file, they would throw up. That had no effect on these brainwashed individuals. They believed him hook, line and sinker.
About a year into prison, this man started attending treatment and as part of the process, he wrote apology letters to many people and admitted his crimes.
That case taught me a valuable lesson about life. Some people only hear WHAT they want to hear from WHO they want to hear it from....
I am sure that is why our country is becoming divided.
Great post. I am very thankful there are people like you willing to do the job you do everyday. I like closing my eyes at night not having to see horrific images such as the ones you’ve had to see which I imagine are burned in your mind. Thank you, keep fighting the good fight!
ReplyDeleteThat is such a horrible case, Scott! It’s a small glimpse into the world that you have to deal with every day. I have stated many times the last year that in this time with social media we are, more than ever, swayed one way or another emotionally. So many sides of one story can be authored with strong persuasion that in one setting I can be convinced I I agree with a particular party and a few scrolls and clicks later, I’ve changed my mind. But that has also caused me to evolve in my ability to not take things at face value and make sure I have the facts straight. I do hope that the majority of people having an awaking during this time of information are also becoming more discerning in there quest for truth.
ReplyDeleteFinding truth is getting harder and harder. I don't want to believe all the horrible things I read about daily but I am grateful to you and others in fields that fight against such horrific crimes committed against children.
ReplyDeleteDon't forget your defense days either. Most people who commit crimes are likable people. There are exceptions of course . . .
ReplyDelete